top of page
GYM CONQUER ジム筋華のブランドイメージ

The Benefits and Risks of Autophagy: The Ultimate Balance

Yare yare daze! Recently, autophagy has been making waves, especially the one-meal-a-day diet gaining popularity. But is this truly beneficial for health? Let's dive into the benefits and risks of autophagy.

A depiction of the benefits and risks of autophagy in the style of Jotaro Kujo, featuring his hat and coat, Stand, the autophagy process within cells, health and nutrition icons, a dynamic background, and the onomatopoeia 'ゴゴゴゴ' and 'ドドドド'.

The Mechanism of Autophagy

Autophagy is the process by which cells break down and recycle their own components. Initially thought to occur only during starvation to generate energy, recent research has shown that autophagy also plays a crucial role in cellular metabolism and the removal of harmful substances.

  • Isolation membrane forms and creates an autophagosome.

  • The autophagosome fuses with a lysosome, breaking down its contents to generate amino acids for reuse.

Benefits: Cellular Renewal and Health Maintenance

The key advantage of autophagy is its ability to eliminate unnecessary or damaged cellular components, leading to several benefits:

  1. Cellular Renewal: Replacing old cells with new ones improves overall function.

  2. Pathogen Removal: Eliminates defective mitochondria, proteins, and pathogens.

Risks: Potential Dangers and Pitfalls

But every path has its shadows. Autophagy also carries certain risks that should not be overlooked.

  1. Nutritional Deficiency: Insufficient nutrients can weaken the immune system. One meal a day may not provide enough protein or fat. At least 1g of protein per kg of body weight is necessary.

  2. Long-term Health Risks: Prolonged calorie restriction or one-meal-a-day diets can harm health, disrupt gut microbiota, and impair nutrient absorption.

  3. Alzheimer's Disease Connection: Excessive autophagy can lead to the accumulation of β-amyloid in cells, increasing the risk of Alzheimer's disease.

Real-World Practice: Ramadan Fasting

One practical example is Ramadan fasting, where food is consumed only between sunset and sunrise. Studies on 43 participants over 28 days showed reductions in BMI, body weight, and fat, but also highlighted risks such as iron deficiency.

New Discoveries and Their Implications

Research from Osaka University revealed that autophagy affects fat cells. It breaks down the inhibitory factor Rubicon, further promoting autophagy. However, this process can lead to fat accumulation in the liver, increasing the risk of fatty liver disease.


Conclusion: Striving for Balance

Short-term autophagy might benefit those with overnutrition. However, long-term practice can pose health risks. Balancing diet, supplements, and moderate food restrictions is essential for maintaining health. Yare yare daze, the journey continues, but with new discoveries, we can better protect our health.


bottom of page